In the year to June 30th, Peloton sold $719.2m of exercise bikes and treadmills and $181.1m of subscriptions.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 On the evening of September 25th it priced its shares at $29, which valued the firm at more than $8bn.2TechCrunchPeloton prices IPO at $29 per share25 Sept 2019 That is about nine times its total revenue, and some 44 times the revenue from the subscriptions that its backers were so keen to discuss. The bike, in other words, was being valued as an afterthought.
The sale raised about $1.16bn from 40m new Class A shares, at the top of the range, and the stock began trading on the Nasdaq the next morning.2TechCrunchPeloton prices IPO at $29 per share25 Sept 2019 It finished the day 11% below the offer price, which left the company worth about $7.2bn, still almost eight times its sales.3FortunePeloton’s market cap is still lofty after its IPO26 Sept 2019 We think the discount was too small. What investors were offered was a fitness-equipment maker with an unusually loyal clientele, and it should be priced as one.
Mostly bike
Peloton revenue by source, year to June 2019, $m
| Revenue | |
|---|---|
| Connected Fitness Products | 719.2 |
| Subscription | 181.1 |
| Other | 14.7 |
Source: Peloton Form S-11
The business is growing fast, and nobody disputes that. Revenue more than doubled, from $435.0m to $915.0m, and subscribers rose from 245,667 to 511,202.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 It is also losing money at the same pace. The net loss was $195.6m, against $47.9m the year before, and the company says it has made operating losses every year since it started in 2012.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 Almost 80% of revenue still comes from selling equipment, which Fortune notes is a business that “mainly depends on making and selling hardware”.3FortunePeloton’s market cap is still lofty after its IPO26 Sept 2019
The pitch is the old razor-and-blades trick, in reverse. Gillette sells the handle cheaply and earns its living on the blades. Peloton makes its sales on the handle and hopes that the blades follow. That can work, but it asks the buyer to believe that each new bike is the down payment on an annuity, and the annuity, so far, is modest. The subscription gross margin was 42.7%, scarcely different from the margin on the hardware, and a long way from what a software firm would hope to report.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 A cheque for $29 a share assumes that the subscriptions will one day dwarf the bikes. In the filing, they are a fifth.
The strongest answer is retention. Peloton reports average net monthly churn of 0.65%, which is to say that fewer than one subscriber in 150 cancels in a month, and the figure has hardly moved in two years.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 Compounded, that is a loss of something under 8% of subscribers a year (our arithmetic). Subscribers also complete 11.5 workouts a month on average, up from 7.5 two years earlier.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 Few software firms can boast of customers who sweat on their product more than ten times a month.
We accept the numbers, and doubt what they prove. More than half of the 511,202 subscribers were added in the past year, so churn has been measured on a young and enthusiastic base, whose members have just paid for a bike and have every reason to use it. Most are on month-to-month terms and can cancel whenever they like, as the company itself warns.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 Loyalty that survives a recession, a rival with a cheaper bike and a bored January is a hypothesis. It is not yet a record. Even if the hypothesis holds, the subscription contribution margin of 50.8% describes a good business, not an extraordinary one.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019
None of this makes Peloton a bad company. The loss from operations of $202.3m is partly the price of building a brand and a content studio, and growth of 110% usually costs money.1SEC EDGARPeloton Interactive, Inc., Form S-1 registration statement27 Aug 2019 The complaint is about the label. Investors who want exposure to a loyal community of cyclists can have it. Those who want a software company should check what is on the shelves.
The market took 11% off in its first session. The bike, it seems, had been noticed.