A company that says it does not need the money has just raised $6.5bn. “Stripe does not need this capital to run its business,” the payments firm said on March 15th, in the same announcement that priced its shares at $50bn.1StripeStripe announces new round of funding and plan to provide employee liquidity15 Mar 2023 Two years earlier it had raised $600m at $95bn.5SiliconANGLEPayment technology company Stripe raises $600M at $95B valuation14 Mar 2021 Reuters Breakingviews calls the new figure “a 47% cut from its 2021 valuation”.3Reuters Breakingviews, via KitcoStripe’s $50 bln reset is relative sign of health16 Mar 2023

The reasons are in the small print. The funds will provide liquidity to current and former employees and cover tax on equity awards, and the firm will retire existing shares to offset the new ones it issues.1StripeStripe announces new round of funding and plan to provide employee liquidity15 Mar 2023 Existing shareholders such as Andreessen Horowitz, Founders Fund and Thrive Capital took part, alongside new investors including GIC, Goldman Sachs Asset and Wealth Management and Temasek.1StripeStripe announces new round of funding and plan to provide employee liquidity15 Mar 2023 It was not a rescue. It was a private company with a tax bill to cover, selling its own stock to people who wanted it.1StripeStripe announces new round of funding and plan to provide employee liquidity15 Mar 2023

We think this is the best way to take a haircut, and an instructive one. The $95bn figure was a mark struck in March 2021, when money was nearly free; by July 2022 Stripe had already cut its own internal valuation to $74bn, according to CNBC, citing the Wall Street Journal, CNBC notes a reported further cut to $63bn in January.2CNBCStripe raises new funding at a sharply reduced $50 billion valuation15 Mar 2023 Founders whose last round dates from that era are carrying a price that nobody has tested. Stripe tested its own, by choice, with a willing buyer, while it could say truthfully that it did not need to. A valuation is a thermometer. It does not cause the fever, and reading it early lets you decide what to do about it.

The firm was not blind to the reading. Last November it cut 14% of its workforce, about 1,120 of 8,000 people, and Patrick Collison, the chief executive, wrote that the firm had been “much too optimistic about the internet economy’s near-term growth in 2022 and 2023” and had “grown operating costs too quickly”.4TechCrunchStripe cuts 14% of its workforce, CEO says they ‘overhired for the world we’re in’3 Nov 2022 A founder who admits both in public has little pride left to protect in a valuation. His brother John, the president, put the next phase simply: “For us, it’s now back to work.”1StripeStripe announces new round of funding and plan to provide employee liquidity15 Mar 2023

The strongest objection is that this is not a real price. Most of the buyers were insiders, runs the argument, and an employee-liquidity round with no fresh money for the business tells you what friends will pay, not what strangers would. That is partly right. Insider support flatters any round, and a public listing remains the harder test. But strangers did turn up, and in size. A sovereign fund and an investment bank’s asset arm do not write cheques out of loyalty. Breakingviews also reckons $50bn is about 3.5 times last year’s gross revenue, against about 4.7 times for Adyen, its Dutch rival, which trades in public.3Reuters Breakingviews, via KitcoStripe’s $50 bln reset is relative sign of health16 Mar 2023 That is a discount, not a fire sale.

For the IPO market, the lesson is that the biggest candidate has lowered its expectations after the Nasdaq’s worst year since 2008.2CNBCStripe raises new funding at a sharply reduced $50 billion valuation15 Mar 2023 In January CNBC reported that Stripe would decide within the next year whether to list.2CNBCStripe raises new funding at a sharply reduced $50 billion valuation15 Mar 2023 John Collison told CNBC in 2021, “We’re very happy as a private company.”2CNBCStripe raises new funding at a sharply reduced $50 billion valuation15 Mar 2023 The round lets him stay happy: it gives staff cash without a listing, which removes the usual excuse for rushing one. That is good for Stripe and bad for bankers. A hundred businesses now handle more than $1bn a year on its platform, which is a fine thing to put in a prospectus.1StripeStripe announces new round of funding and plan to provide employee liquidity15 Mar 2023 Nobody needs the prospectus yet.

The lesson for founders is blunter. A down round at a firm that is growing is an embarrassment. A down round forced on a firm that has run out of cash is an emergency. The difference is whether you choose the timing, and Stripe chose.

Venture capitalists like to say that the market is always right. Stripe has just agreed, on its own schedule.