For almost ten years, an iPhone user could subscribe to a music service through an app and not be told, by that app, that the same subscription was cheaper elsewhere.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024 On March 4th the European Commission fined Apple “over €1.8 billion” for the arrangement.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024 Margrethe Vestager, the Commission’s competition chief, was blunt: Apple had abused its dominant position in music-streaming distribution for close to a decade.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024

The mechanism is simple. Apple charges developers a 30% commission on subscriptions sold through its in-app purchase system.2European CommissionAntitrust: Commission opens investigations into Apple’s App Store rules16 Jun 2020 A developer that wants to avoid the commission can sell on its own website. Under Apple’s rules, though, it could not tell iPhone users about cheaper prices, link to its site from the app, or email newly acquired customers about alternatives.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024 The Commission says those provisions were “neither necessary nor proportionate” and may have left many iOS users paying “significantly higher prices”.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024

The case began with a complaint from Spotify, Apple’s music rival, on March 11th 2019.2European CommissionAntitrust: Commission opens investigations into Apple’s App Store rules16 Jun 2020 The Commission opened formal proceedings in June 2020, sent a statement of objections in April 2021 and replaced it with a second in February 2023.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024,2European CommissionAntitrust: Commission opens investigations into Apple’s App Store rules16 Jun 2020,3European CommissionAntitrust: Commission sends Statement of Objections to Apple on App Store rules for music streaming providers30 Apr 2021 That is five years from complaint to decision. Apple is “currently the sole provider” of an app store for iPhone users in Europe, so a streaming firm has no other door to knock on.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024

We think the verdict is correct. A platform may charge for its services; Apple is entitled to be paid for a store that brings customers to developers. It is not entitled to forbid those developers from mentioning that the store is not the only place to buy. That is a gag, not a price. A dominant firm that polices what its rivals may say to shared customers is doing something no rent can justify. The Commission also noted that Apple supplied incorrect information during the procedure, which did Apple no favours.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024

The size of the fine is a harder question. The Commission added a lump sum of €1.8bn to a basic amount, because “a significant part of the harm caused by the infringement consists of non-monetary harm” that a revenue-based method cannot capture.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024 The headline is almost entirely the lump sum. The sum may be defensible; the reasoning is not easily tested. Courts will find it hard to review a penalty whose largest part rests on harm the regulator says it cannot count. Such a fine invites a long appeal, and Apple has the money to run one.

The strongest objection comes from the other side. Apple’s defenders say the fine is a rounding error, and that a firm of Apple’s size will pay it and carry on. The Commission, for its part, calls the amount “proportionate to Apple’s global revenues” and “sufficiently deterrent”.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024 Perhaps. But the fine was never the main event. The Commission has also ordered Apple to remove the anti-steering provisions and not to repeat the practice or adopt anything with an equivalent effect.1European CommissionCommission fines Apple over €1.8 billion over abusive App Store rules for music streaming providers4 Mar 2024 That order, not the cheque, will change what iPhone users see. A developer free to say that a subscription is cheaper elsewhere has a competitive tool that no fine can supply.

That is where the Commission should now spend its effort. The test of the decision is whether music apps can actually tell their customers about alternatives in a way that works, rather than in a way that technically complies. Apple has a record of reading rules in its own favour. Regulators who take a ten-year case should expect a ten-year argument about wording.

Apple spent a decade teaching developers to stay quiet. Brussels has now sent it a bill for €1.8bn, which is a way of teaching that silence has a price.