Meta has built parental controls for years, and its own president of global affairs says parents do not use them. Nick Clegg made the point to reporters last week, according to the Associated Press.2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 On September 17th the company announced what is, in effect, its answer: stop asking parents to opt in, and put the teenagers in the safe version of the app instead.

From that day every new Instagram account for someone under 18 is a Teen Account, and existing teenagers will be moved over the next 60 days, starting in America, Britain, Canada and Australia, with the European Union later this year.1MetaIntroducing Instagram Teen Accounts: Built-In Protections for Teens, Peace of Mind for Parents17 Sept 2024 2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 The account is private, so a teenager must approve each new follower. Messages can come only from people the teenager follows or is already connected to. The most restrictive setting for sensitive content, such as fight videos and cosmetic-surgery promotions, is switched on. A notification appears after 60 minutes a day, and a sleep mode mutes alerts from 10pm to 7am.1MetaIntroducing Instagram Teen Accounts: Built-In Protections for Teens, Peace of Mind for Parents17 Sept 2024 2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024

We think this is the right design, and the reason is not that the settings are novel. Most are old options with new addresses. The reason is that a default is a decision made on behalf of everyone who never opens the settings menu, and that is most of them. A control that needs a parent to find it, understand it and press it is a control for the already-engaged. Mr Clegg’s complaint was a description of how people behave, and Meta has finally designed for it.

The sensible objection is about motive. Dozens of American states have sued Meta, alleging that it knowingly built features that addict children, and Letitia James, New York’s attorney general, called the announcement “an important first step, but much more needs to be done.”2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 A company in the dock has every reason to tidy its settings. Critics also note that earlier changes fell short; the 60-minute reminder, for instance, can be dismissed unless parents turn on supervision.2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024

That is fair as far as it goes, but design is judged by what it does, not why it was done. A private account that a stranger cannot message is private whether it was built from conviction or from litigation. Vivek Murthy, America’s surgeon general, complained in 2023 that tech firms ask parents “to manage a technology that’s rapidly evolving”.2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 Moving the burden from the parent to the platform answers that complaint directly.

The weak points are two. The first is age. A Teen Account is only as good as the birthday typed at sign-up, and Meta concedes that teenagers may lie. It says it will require age checks in more situations, such as when someone makes a new account with an adult birthday, and is building technology to find teenagers posing as adults.2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 That technology is promised, not shown. The second is the exit. Those under 16 need a parent’s permission to loosen a setting; 16- and 17-year-olds can switch the protections off themselves.1MetaIntroducing Instagram Teen Accounts: Built-In Protections for Teens, Peace of Mind for Parents17 Sept 2024 2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 A default that its target can disable alone is a default only until the first curious Saturday night.

Parents, meanwhile, keep a role. Teenagers who want to relax a setting must set up supervision, which lets a parent see whom the child messaged in the past seven days, though not what was said.1MetaIntroducing Instagram Teen Accounts: Built-In Protections for Teens, Peace of Mind for Parents17 Sept 2024 3InstagramIntroducing Instagram Teen Accounts: Built-In Protections for Teens, Peace of Mind for Parents17 Sept 2024 Naomi Gleit, Meta’s head of product, expects this to create a “big incentive for parents and teens to set up parental supervision.”2Associated Press, via PBS NewsHourInstagram introducing private teen accounts amid growing backlash over safety17 Sept 2024 That is a bet that teenagers will accept a parent in their settings in exchange for a looser app. Teenagers have been known to decline such bargains.

So the test is simple, and Meta can run it. Publish, a year from now, the share of teenagers who remain in Teen Accounts, and how many came in by lying about their age. A default that sticks is a policy. One that people routinely leave is a press release with a sleep mode.